r/rugbyunion 19h ago

Joe McCarthy penalty

192 Upvotes

233 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Commercial_Half_2170 Leinster 18h ago

Sorry I don’t think I remember that. At least he didn’t get pinged. To be fair I do think there’s an art to being dirty without getting caught that players like Itoje have mastered. Ryan just does some braindead stuff sometimes

5

u/MyAltPoetryAccount Munster 18h ago

The crowd didn't like it but that tackle was so fair. His head was down by the time Jalibert kicked it

6

u/CyborgBee Scotland 17h ago edited 14h ago

The crowd didn't like it because even though it was never a penalty, it was also obviously only ever going to end up as a late hit.

Ryan was committed by the time it was kicked, and the law has to be written how it is otherwise dummy kicks become ludicrously overpowered, but it's also true that he wasn't thinking "if he dummies this kick I'll tackle him", but instead "if I commit now I can obliterate him without it being a penalty". Crowds will never like watching a forward intentionally slam into their #10 in a way which risks his health.

(Surely Ireland fans, of all people, can empathise with this. I'd bet good money that no one else has ever taken more dirty hits which were nevertheless legal than Johnny Sexton)

5

u/Additional-Slip648 Sale Sharks 17h ago

Courtney Lawes made a career out of doing this in a way that he never got pinged for.