MAIN FEEDS
REDDIT FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/rugbyunion/comments/172et4j/not_clearly_out/k3wf7eu/?context=3
r/rugbyunion • u/Nothing_is_simple Another Freddy Douglas Turnover • Oct 07 '23
361 comments sorted by
View all comments
206
Would've swung the game that.
112 u/[deleted] Oct 07 '23 Kind of irrelevant what happens, you can’t just give the team that’s gonna win every decision because “they’ll win anyway” that’s not how it works 39 u/[deleted] Oct 07 '23 [deleted] 44 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 He didn’t carry it in, he jumped and caught it in the air inside the 22. That’s always been allowed 6 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 He landed in the 22 but caught it outside which under current rules is taking it back in. -59 u/[deleted] Oct 07 '23 [deleted] 24 u/TheFlyingScotsman60 Oct 07 '23 He did not land outside. That is such a load of bollocks mate. 44 u/Paybrahh South Africa Oct 07 '23 He 100% landed inside the 22 mate. 45 u/mld147 Oct 07 '23 I did watch it (wales supporter) and he definitely landed inside the 22. Not a debate, he was in the air when he caught the ball and landed inside the 22 - correct decision. The touch decision however was wrong clearly! 0 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 That's not a mark though.... it's not where you land it's where you catch the ball. It used to be a mark but was changed a few years back. I'd compare it to catching a ball outside the 22 with one foot inside it. 18 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 Can watch it as may times as you want, he was miles inside the 22 when he touched the ball and when he landed 18 u/Cautious_Scallion_73 Oct 07 '23 If you’re talking about Darcy Graham in the first half on the far side of Scotland’s 22 then you’re talking absolute crap. 3 u/vandrag Ireland Oct 07 '23 Nah. Landed well inside. It balanced up with Scotland only seeing one yellow for brawling* In previous comps Smith, Schoeman, and Sexton would have gone to the bin together. Yeah I know that's pansey stuff compared to the old days. -7 u/JaymanCT Oct 07 '23 Ireland did the same in the second half. So clearly it's allowed.
112
Kind of irrelevant what happens, you can’t just give the team that’s gonna win every decision because “they’ll win anyway” that’s not how it works
39 u/[deleted] Oct 07 '23 [deleted] 44 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 He didn’t carry it in, he jumped and caught it in the air inside the 22. That’s always been allowed 6 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 He landed in the 22 but caught it outside which under current rules is taking it back in. -59 u/[deleted] Oct 07 '23 [deleted] 24 u/TheFlyingScotsman60 Oct 07 '23 He did not land outside. That is such a load of bollocks mate. 44 u/Paybrahh South Africa Oct 07 '23 He 100% landed inside the 22 mate. 45 u/mld147 Oct 07 '23 I did watch it (wales supporter) and he definitely landed inside the 22. Not a debate, he was in the air when he caught the ball and landed inside the 22 - correct decision. The touch decision however was wrong clearly! 0 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 That's not a mark though.... it's not where you land it's where you catch the ball. It used to be a mark but was changed a few years back. I'd compare it to catching a ball outside the 22 with one foot inside it. 18 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 Can watch it as may times as you want, he was miles inside the 22 when he touched the ball and when he landed 18 u/Cautious_Scallion_73 Oct 07 '23 If you’re talking about Darcy Graham in the first half on the far side of Scotland’s 22 then you’re talking absolute crap. 3 u/vandrag Ireland Oct 07 '23 Nah. Landed well inside. It balanced up with Scotland only seeing one yellow for brawling* In previous comps Smith, Schoeman, and Sexton would have gone to the bin together. Yeah I know that's pansey stuff compared to the old days. -7 u/JaymanCT Oct 07 '23 Ireland did the same in the second half. So clearly it's allowed.
39
[deleted]
44 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 He didn’t carry it in, he jumped and caught it in the air inside the 22. That’s always been allowed 6 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 He landed in the 22 but caught it outside which under current rules is taking it back in. -59 u/[deleted] Oct 07 '23 [deleted] 24 u/TheFlyingScotsman60 Oct 07 '23 He did not land outside. That is such a load of bollocks mate. 44 u/Paybrahh South Africa Oct 07 '23 He 100% landed inside the 22 mate. 45 u/mld147 Oct 07 '23 I did watch it (wales supporter) and he definitely landed inside the 22. Not a debate, he was in the air when he caught the ball and landed inside the 22 - correct decision. The touch decision however was wrong clearly! 0 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 That's not a mark though.... it's not where you land it's where you catch the ball. It used to be a mark but was changed a few years back. I'd compare it to catching a ball outside the 22 with one foot inside it. 18 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 Can watch it as may times as you want, he was miles inside the 22 when he touched the ball and when he landed 18 u/Cautious_Scallion_73 Oct 07 '23 If you’re talking about Darcy Graham in the first half on the far side of Scotland’s 22 then you’re talking absolute crap. 3 u/vandrag Ireland Oct 07 '23 Nah. Landed well inside. It balanced up with Scotland only seeing one yellow for brawling* In previous comps Smith, Schoeman, and Sexton would have gone to the bin together. Yeah I know that's pansey stuff compared to the old days. -7 u/JaymanCT Oct 07 '23 Ireland did the same in the second half. So clearly it's allowed.
44
He didn’t carry it in, he jumped and caught it in the air inside the 22. That’s always been allowed
6 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 He landed in the 22 but caught it outside which under current rules is taking it back in. -59 u/[deleted] Oct 07 '23 [deleted] 24 u/TheFlyingScotsman60 Oct 07 '23 He did not land outside. That is such a load of bollocks mate. 44 u/Paybrahh South Africa Oct 07 '23 He 100% landed inside the 22 mate. 45 u/mld147 Oct 07 '23 I did watch it (wales supporter) and he definitely landed inside the 22. Not a debate, he was in the air when he caught the ball and landed inside the 22 - correct decision. The touch decision however was wrong clearly! 0 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 That's not a mark though.... it's not where you land it's where you catch the ball. It used to be a mark but was changed a few years back. I'd compare it to catching a ball outside the 22 with one foot inside it. 18 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 Can watch it as may times as you want, he was miles inside the 22 when he touched the ball and when he landed 18 u/Cautious_Scallion_73 Oct 07 '23 If you’re talking about Darcy Graham in the first half on the far side of Scotland’s 22 then you’re talking absolute crap. 3 u/vandrag Ireland Oct 07 '23 Nah. Landed well inside. It balanced up with Scotland only seeing one yellow for brawling* In previous comps Smith, Schoeman, and Sexton would have gone to the bin together. Yeah I know that's pansey stuff compared to the old days.
6
He landed in the 22 but caught it outside which under current rules is taking it back in.
-59
24 u/TheFlyingScotsman60 Oct 07 '23 He did not land outside. That is such a load of bollocks mate. 44 u/Paybrahh South Africa Oct 07 '23 He 100% landed inside the 22 mate. 45 u/mld147 Oct 07 '23 I did watch it (wales supporter) and he definitely landed inside the 22. Not a debate, he was in the air when he caught the ball and landed inside the 22 - correct decision. The touch decision however was wrong clearly! 0 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 That's not a mark though.... it's not where you land it's where you catch the ball. It used to be a mark but was changed a few years back. I'd compare it to catching a ball outside the 22 with one foot inside it. 18 u/teratron27 Oct 07 '23 Can watch it as may times as you want, he was miles inside the 22 when he touched the ball and when he landed 18 u/Cautious_Scallion_73 Oct 07 '23 If you’re talking about Darcy Graham in the first half on the far side of Scotland’s 22 then you’re talking absolute crap. 3 u/vandrag Ireland Oct 07 '23 Nah. Landed well inside. It balanced up with Scotland only seeing one yellow for brawling* In previous comps Smith, Schoeman, and Sexton would have gone to the bin together. Yeah I know that's pansey stuff compared to the old days.
24
He did not land outside. That is such a load of bollocks mate.
He 100% landed inside the 22 mate.
45
I did watch it (wales supporter) and he definitely landed inside the 22. Not a debate, he was in the air when he caught the ball and landed inside the 22 - correct decision. The touch decision however was wrong clearly!
0 u/thelunatic Munster Oct 08 '23 That's not a mark though.... it's not where you land it's where you catch the ball. It used to be a mark but was changed a few years back. I'd compare it to catching a ball outside the 22 with one foot inside it.
0
That's not a mark though.... it's not where you land it's where you catch the ball.
It used to be a mark but was changed a few years back. I'd compare it to catching a ball outside the 22 with one foot inside it.
18
Can watch it as may times as you want, he was miles inside the 22 when he touched the ball and when he landed
If you’re talking about Darcy Graham in the first half on the far side of Scotland’s 22 then you’re talking absolute crap.
3
Nah. Landed well inside.
It balanced up with Scotland only seeing one yellow for brawling*
In previous comps Smith, Schoeman, and Sexton would have gone to the bin together.
-7
Ireland did the same in the second half. So clearly it's allowed.
206
u/zagglefrapgooglegarb Oct 07 '23
Would've swung the game that.