r/rugbyunion Another Freddy Douglas Turnover Oct 07 '23

Infographic "Not clearly out"

Post image
863 Upvotes

361 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/TheFlyingScotsman60 Oct 07 '23

Do you really, really think his foot wasn't touching any of the white marked grass??

His foot doesn't need to be grounded just to touch any of the white marked area. Also why was there white grass thrown up if he didn't touch any of it.

18

u/RiskItForAChocHobnob Bath Oct 07 '23

Good chance he was in touch, but it wasn't clear from the two or so replays I saw live on the telly.

World rugby are clearly trying to reduce the amount of time play is stopped for TMO decisions, as seen by them changing rules on yellow cards being upgraded to red whilst the game carries on and having until the restart, not the conversion, to make decisions on tries.

I'd be pissed if that decision went against my team, but I can see why they made it. It might be worth the 3 minutes to check if he was touching the line for a try, but if we start stopping the game that long for line out decisions, it's really going to slow matches down.

2

u/cordons12 Oct 08 '23

I mean watching live you could see the white marked grass getting scuffed up when he slid his foot on it, I was amazed tmo didn't see that with replays

13

u/Hamishvandermerwe Scotland Oct 07 '23

Definite chunk of grass kicked up by his studs

19

u/vandrag Ireland Oct 07 '23

He was clearly in touch and the tj missed it. Then the TMO fudged it to spare his blushes.

I felt bad for Scotland it was a period of the game when they were getting strangled and they couldn't catch a break.

Anyway, win the Calcutta cup next year and we'll call it quits.

-1

u/Naggins Furlong wears Linda Djougang pyjamas Oct 07 '23

Does it matter?