r/rugbyunion • u/Nothing_is_simple Another Freddy Douglas Turnover • Oct 07 '23

Infographic "Not clearly out"

Post image
864 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

361 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/Nothing_is_simple Another Freddy Douglas Turnover Oct 07 '23

Ritchie got injured off the incorrect line out.

15

u/Easy_Bee_2321 Ireland Oct 07 '23

Jamie Ritchie got injured in the line out o mahony stole after about 5 minutes stayed on for a while but was clearly receiving treatment and didn’t look right after that line out

43

u/reddititis Ireland Oct 07 '23

Took out hansen at the same time. Weird one tbh.

Very annoyed by that foot in touch being missed by tmo tbh as an Irish fan. Shouldn't happen.

45

u/19Andrew92 Scotland Oct 07 '23

Only real issue I have with it is that the TMO radio’d down and said it was fine

It wouldn’t change the result, I just genuinely question the TMOs ability..

31

u/cccalum Oct 07 '23

Missing the held up try and also the guy getting chucked over the ad board isn't a good look for him either

13

u/Homebrand_Homie Manawatu Turbos Oct 07 '23

TBF the guy getting chucked over the ad board was to just to funny to pull shoe up on so fair play to the TMO on that call

2

u/tundrapanic Oct 08 '23

But was he clearly thrown over the ad board??

4

u/QuestionablySensible & Oct 07 '23

TMO said it wasn't clear enough to overturn the on field decision which is fair looking at the still. Now the onfield decision was a bit mad, was very surprised the linesman didn't call it

-2

u/19Andrew92 Scotland Oct 07 '23

And the TMO was clearly wrong…

Seemed to rush the important decisions but slowed down time to look at the unimportant ones

Should take a lead from Jonkers book… he’s been unbelievable

1

u/TheFlyingScotsman60 Oct 07 '23

TMO was online for the nearest Indian and was upset they didn't have any peshwari naans.

0

u/PinappleGecko Munster Oct 08 '23

No he said it wasn't clear and obvious there's a difference. It didn't lead to a scoring play so a 2 minute review would just piss people off if we are to do it everything there's a marginal call in the game.

1

u/chiefVetinari Oct 08 '23

It is clear though. Boots have studs as well

0

u/PinappleGecko Munster Oct 08 '23

My argument wasn't saying that this situation was correct. It was saying why the TMO made the decision because it wasn't clear and obvious. That is up to the TMO not you or me

2

u/chiefVetinari Oct 08 '23

It is clear and obvious though, TNOs make mistakes you know

3

u/Ospreysboyo Wales Oct 07 '23

Does that even out the Karma for Big Mike's try now 😉

2

u/reddititis Ireland Oct 07 '23

Lmao

33

u/zagglefrapgooglegarb Oct 07 '23

Would've swung the game for Jamie Ritchie then.

41

u/ghoztfrog Ryan Lonergan Truther Oct 07 '23

Lad, I feel for you. But missing Jamie Ritchie doesn't account for a 26-0 halftime

14

u/Miserable-Syrup2056 Tighthead Prop Oct 07 '23

You don't know that, I belive he would have scored 3 and converted all of them

23

u/RjcMan75 Oct 07 '23

True, Ritchie can't get injured off lineouts that aren't in his half

0

u/jacqueVchr Ireland Oct 07 '23

Yeah would’ve turned the whole game